Some people make content look effortless. You scroll past their posts and think, Wow, they really have it figured out. But if there's one thing Cindy Allman, also known as Book of Cinz, wants you to know, it's this: social media is not real life. What looks like an overnight success is often years of consistency, trial and error, and a deep commitment to showing up.
In this edition of The Digital Insider’s Strat Chat, I sat down with Cindy to discuss how she built a thriving brand around books, travel, and community, why consistency matters more than perfection, and the challenges of monetization in the creator economy.
From Passion to Platform
Cindy’s journey started with a simple love of reading. She wanted a space to talk about books, especially Caribbean literature, and so she created one. What began as a small Instagram page evolved into a multi-platform brand with an engaged audience across TikTok, Twitter, Instagram, and an email newsletter.
But it wasn’t overnight. She’s been at it for seven years.
“I always say that social media is not a real place, and we have to remember that everyone’s journey is different,” she says. “People look at where you are now and compare it to where they are, but they don’t see the years of work behind the scenes.”
One of the turning points for Cindy’s brand was launching Read Caribbean, an initiative celebrating Caribbean authors and literature. That simple idea turned into an annual movement, growing her audience and deepening her niche. Over time, Book of Cinz expanded to include book clubs, reading retreats, and lifestyle content about the Caribbean.
Building an Engaged Community
If there’s one thing Cindy does exceptionally well, it’s building an engaged audience. Her followers don’t just scroll past her content; they actively participate in her book club, attend her reading retreats, and open her emails.
So, what’s the secret?
Differentiating brand based on the audience on each platform. “For TikTok, I'm a lot more laid back. I am a lot more in my Cindy Caribbean girl content creator or storyteller. I feel like sometimes I'm like, maybe I should delete this video because this is just too raw. And I feel like I share opinions and I'm just like, it's more unedited. Instagram is a little more curated, and Twitter is just where I hop in and out of conversations.”
Consistency. “A lot of people say they don’t have an engaged audience, but the real issue is inconsistency. I’ve been showing up for years.”
Storytelling. “People don’t follow you just for information. They follow for personality and story.”
Multi-platform presence. “I don’t rely on just one platform. I have my newsletter, my book club, my retreats. It’s an ecosystem.”
She also emphasizes the importance of moving beyond social media. “If TikTok disappears tomorrow, what do you have? That’s why I’m focused on my email list and website. That’s where I have control.”
The Business of Passion
Many creators struggle with the balance between passion and profit. Cindy admits that monetization has been tricky, especially when audiences expect free content.
“I provide book recommendations, host free book clubs, send newsletters, create social content, and then when I say, ‘Hey, I’m hosting a retreat, you can pay to attend,’ people suddenly go quiet.”
Despite the challenges, Cindy has successfully turned her brand into a business. She has partnerships with brands like Samsung, tourism boards, and airlines, and she hosts reading retreats in stunning Caribbean locations. Her advice for creators looking to monetize?
Pitch strategically. “I don’t pitch to just any brand. It has to align with my values and audience.”
Build multiple revenue streams. “My email list is where I have real influence. It’s not just about social media.”
Be patient. “I think like two years now or probably two and a half years, brands started reaching out and then I started pitching to brands. So like, it's a mix of two different things where I'm like, okay, let me reach out and, or they would reach out and I'd do that so that's how it starts and I guess also remaining consistent like just having a plan for your platform and just knowing that you're going to show up.”
What’s Next?
Cindy has big plans for Book of Cinz. She’s revamping her website, expanding her reading retreats to six Caribbean islands, and continuing to grow her book club. Her ultimate goal? To make Caribbean literature mainstream and create a platform that bridges books, travel, and culture.
“If it was strategic, I would probably start off as a lifestyle Caribbean curator. I'm like, okay, there's so many things I can do with this. But I'm like, nobody reads. Nobody's going to follow me. Nobody's going to like anything. I'm like, I'm just doing this because I want to showcase my reading and talk about books and find that community.”
Key Takeaways for Creators:
Start with what you love. Passion is a better foundation than strategy alone.
Be consistent. Success takes years, not months.
Tell stories. People connect with people, not just information.
Diversify your platforms. Don’t build your house on rented land (aka social media).
Charge for your expertise. Free content is great, but sustainable businesses need revenue.
Want more insights like this? Make sure to subscribe to The Digital Insider for in-depth chats with digital creators, entrepreneurs, and marketing pros who are making waves online.
📌 Follow Cindy Almond:
Instagram: @bookofcinz
Twitter: @bookofcinz
TikTok: @bookofcinz
Website: bookofcinz.com
What are your biggest takeaways from Cindy’s journey? Drop a comment below and let’s discuss!
Share this post